realestateagent.club

Glossary

Sales comparison approach

Valuation method deriving value from prices of comparable properties; common for flats.

What the Vergleichswertverfahren is

The Vergleichswertverfahren, the comparative value method, is one of three standardised valuation approaches used in Germany, alongside the income capitalisation method (Ertragswertverfahren) and the cost method (Sachwertverfahren). It determines a property's value by directly referencing actually achieved purchase prices of sufficiently comparable properties, or by applying comparative factors published by official valuation boards.

Legal basis and data source

The method is set out in the Immobilienwertermittlungsverordnung (ImmoWertV), the Real Estate Valuation Ordinance. Each German state operates local Gutachterausschüsse für Grundstückswerte (expert committees for land values), typically organised at municipal or county level, which anonymously collect actual purchase prices from notarised contracts in a purchase price register (Kaufpreissammlung) and derive, among other outputs, standard land values (Bodenrichtwerte) and comparative factors.

How it works

For a valid comparison, the reference properties must be sufficiently similar in key value-relevant characteristics such as location, size, year of construction, condition and fittings; any differences are adjusted through appropriate surcharges or deductions. This method is particularly well suited to property types that are traded frequently and in large numbers, such as condominium apartments in larger cities, where robust comparable data is available.

A key limitation

A crucial methodological point is that asking prices listed on property portals are not the same as actual transaction prices and are therefore not, on their own, a sound basis for comparison, since they can reflect negotiating room, overpricing, or properties that never actually sold at the listed price.

Practical tips

A frequent mistake, especially among buyers and sellers researching independently, is to equate online listing-price research with a properly conducted comparative valuation, when the latter requires access to genuine, realised transaction prices. The local Gutachterausschuss and publicly appointed, sworn valuation experts have access to the relevant purchase price registers and can produce a methodologically sound valuation where one is needed, for example for tax, inheritance or dispute purposes.

Related services

Related terms

General information, not legal or tax advice.